I would refer anyone who has any doubts about the existence of an Apple license to take a look at readily available public documents as stated previously by Lamberts. Start with the info below from Chuck Moore's complaint, then look closely at Phil Marcoux's (re: Chipscale) complaint which clearly mentions Apple....oh but please don't stop there. If you look, you can find it.
52. In addition, in or about April 2010, PTSC became aware that TPL, without notice or authorization, had commingled an MMP Portfolio license with other portfolios, including, upon information and belief, the “Chipscale” portfolio in which TPL by then had no rights, and other portfolios owned by TPL and licensed the result to a major Silicon Valley electronics and cell phone firm. The major component, by any measure, of that license was a license of the MMP Portfolio, TPL and the Defendants, without notice or authorization, upon information and belief, elected to attribute only five percent (5%) of what was upon information and belief a multimillion-dollar licensing fee to the MMP Portfolio. PTSC filed action against TPL and Defendant Alliacense for its deception.
